Gender-Based Legal Inequality in Islam
Built Into the System
Modern defenders of Islam often claim it honors and uplifts women. But when we turn to Islamic law — not slogans — a very different picture emerges.
Gender inequality in Islam isn’t cultural. It’s legal.
It’s not a misinterpretation. It’s institutional.
And it’s not marginal. It’s mainstream.
From testimony in court to inheritance, from marriage rights to dress codes, women under Islamic law are systemically treated as less than men — by divine decree.
⚖️ Unequal in Court: A Woman’s Word Is Worth Half
“Call two witnesses from among your men. If two men cannot be found, then one man and two women...”
— Qur’an 2:282
According to the Qur’an itself, two women are needed to equal the legal testimony of one man. Classical jurists explicitly state this is due to women’s "deficient intellect" — not cultural context.
The result? In any legal case, a woman’s voice is halved before she even speaks.
💰 Inheritance: Women Get Less by Law
“For the male, a share equal to that of two females.”
— Qur’an 4:11
This isn’t flexible. It’s prescriptive divine law: a daughter inherits half of what a son does.
The justification? Male financial responsibility. But even where that doesn’t apply, the rule stays. Because it’s “from Allah.”
It’s not equity. It’s not context-sensitive.
It’s sex-based discrimination embedded in scripture.
💍 Marriage: Men Rule, Women Obey
Islamic marriage law creates a hierarchy, not a partnership:
-
Men are guardians (qawwamun) over women — Qur’an 4:34
-
A husband can beat his wife for disobedience — Qur’an 4:34
-
A man can marry up to four women — Qur’an 4:3
-
A woman can marry only one man
-
A man can divorce his wife unilaterally
-
A woman needs permission from a male guardian to marry
This isn’t just imbalance. This is codified male dominance.
👗 Dress Code: Only Women Are Legislated into Modesty
Nowhere does the Qur’an order men to cover their entire bodies. But women?
“Tell believing women to lower their gaze and guard their private parts and not display their adornment except what is apparent...”
— Qur’an 24:31
“And tell them to draw their veils over their bosoms...”
— same verse
The burden of modesty — and the blame for temptation — is placed squarely on women’s shoulders. Always.
🧕 In the Real World: Sharia in Action
In many Muslim-majority countries where Sharia is practiced — either fully or partially — these inequalities become hard law:
-
Saudi Arabia: Until recently, women couldn’t drive or travel without a male guardian. Still requires male approval for many legal actions.
-
Iran: Women must cover fully by law; disobedience punishable by fines, lashes, or prison.
-
Pakistan, Afghanistan, Somalia: Testimony and inheritance laws favor men.
-
Egypt, Sudan, UAE: Marital obedience laws still recognized in Sharia courts.
This isn’t isolated. This is systemic. Wherever Islamic law is enforced, gender hierarchy follows.
🧼 Common Excuses — Debunked
“It was progressive for its time.”
→ That may be historically true. But if it’s from God, it should transcend time — not be frozen in a 7th-century mindset.
“Women are spiritually equal.”
→ Maybe — but in court, in money, in marriage, in life? Not under the law.
“Men and women have different roles.”
→ That’s the language of patriarchy with a divine stamp. And the “roles” always place men on top.
🎯 Final Word
A legal system that defines a woman’s worth as half a man’s is not divine. It’s patriarchal.
Islam doesn’t merely reflect ancient sexism — it preserves and protects it under the name of God.
Gender inequality in Islam is not a glitch. It’s not a misreading.
It’s written into the Qur’an. Modeled by Muhammad. Enforced through Sharia.
Any claim that Islam liberates women must first explain why its laws consistently strip them of equal rights.
Until that happens, it’s not liberation.
It’s legalized, moralized subjugation.
No comments:
Post a Comment